Chapter 1. The Design Process and Design Skills FREE
1.1 Technology in Grade 9
Grade 9 is the final year of Technology in the GET band. At the end of this year you choose your FET subjects, and everything you practise now, working to a design brief, drawing formal plans, calculating costs and forces, feeds directly into subjects such as Engineering Graphics and Design, Civil, Mechanical and Electrical Technology.
The big step up from Grade 8 is this: in Grade 9 you must be able to identify a problem, need or opportunity from a given real-life context. In earlier grades the problem was handed to you. Now you read a scenario, a community cut off by a river, a kitchen tool that injures users, a school hall with poor lighting, and you decide what the real problem is before any designing starts.
The year covers the four core content areas of Technology: Structures (Term 1), Mechanical Systems and Control (Term 2), Electrical and Electronic Systems and Control (Term 3) and Processing (Term 4). Holding all of it together is the design process.
1.2 The design process
The design process has five skills: Investigate, Design, Make, Evaluate and Communicate. Remember them with the letters IDMEC.
The diagram shows the skills in a cycle around the problem, and that is the key point: the process is not a straight line. You evaluate at every step. A designer might investigate, sketch two ideas, evaluate them, go back and investigate more, adapt the design, and only then start making. Evaluation drives the whole process.
1.3 Investigate
Investigation means finding out everything you need before and while you design:
- The context and the people. Who is affected? What exactly do they need? What is the environment like?
- Existing products. Study products that already try to solve the problem. Compare them against the key design aspects: fitness-for-purpose, cost, safety, ergonomics (is it easy and comfortable to use?), aesthetics (does it look good?), environmental impact, and possible bias towards or against a group of users.
- Information sources. In Grade 9 you must locate, compare and cross-check different sources before you trust them, and acknowledge where information comes from.
Investigation can happen at any point in the process, it is not a stage you finish and leave behind.
1.4 Design: the design brief, specifications and constraints
Once you understand the problem, you write a design brief: a short, clear statement of what will be designed, for whom, and why. In Grade 9 you write it without assistance. The brief is followed by:
- Specifications: exact requirements the solution must meet: sizes, functions, materials, safety features.
- Constraints: the limits you must work within: maximum cost, available time, tools and materials at hand.
Worked example: a wheelchair ramp. A learner who uses a wheelchair cannot reach the school stoep, which is 600 mm above the ground.
- Design brief: Design and build a safe, permanent ramp so that a wheelchair user can move from the ground onto the stoep without help.
- Specifications: gradient no steeper than 1:12; surface width at least 1000 mm; non-slip surface; handrail at a height of 900 mm on both sides.
- Constraints: total cost at most R900; must be finished within two weekends; only materials from the local hardware store.
The gradient specification lets us calculate the ramp length. A gradient of 1:12 means the ramp may rise at most 1 mm for every 12 mm it runs. The stoep is 600 mm high, so the minimum ramp length is 600 x 12 = 7200 mm = 7,2 m. A specification with a number in it is testable, that is what makes it useful when you evaluate later.
1.5 Make: working drawings, flow charts and costing
Making starts on paper. Before any cutting you produce:
- Working drawings in first-angle orthographic projection (Section 1.8 and Chapter 2), accurate, to scale, fully dimensioned, so that somebody else could build your design from them.
- A flow chart: the sequence of manufacture, step by step, so the team knows what happens in what order.
- A budget. Grade 9 costing must be realistic and must include labour, because real projects pay real people.
Worked example: budget for a small garden bench:
| Item | Calculation | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Pine planks, 4 m at R60 per metre | 4 x R60 | R240 |
| Screws and brackets | - | R35 |
| Waterproof paint, 1 tin | - | R85 |
| Materials subtotal | R240 + R35 + R85 | R360 |
| Labour, 3 hours at R120 per hour | 3 x R120 | R360 |
| Total cost | R360 + R360 | R720 |
While you build, work safely: correct tool for the job, blades away from the body, eye protection when cutting or drilling, and a tidy workspace.
1.6 Evaluate
Evaluation means testing the solution, and the process you followed, against the design brief and every specification, one by one. Did the ramp gradient come out at 1:12 or better? Is the surface really non-slip? Did the project stay under R900? You then suggest sensible improvements. Evaluation must be objective: judge against the written criteria, not against how hard the team worked.
Use the key design aspects as your checklist: fitness-for-purpose and suitability of materials, value for money, safety and ergonomics, aesthetics, ease of manufacture, environmental impact, and bias towards or against any group.
1.7 Communicate: three kinds of drawing
You record and present your work throughout the process. In Technology, drawing is split into three fields, each with its own job:
- Free-hand sketches in the design stage, quick 3D ideas with notes.
- Working drawings in the making stage, formal, to scale, using the drawing conventions.
- Artistic impressions in the communication stage, perspective drawings with colour, texture, shading and shadows, used to sell the idea.
Working drawings follow strict conventions so that any reader, in any language, understands them. The most important convention is the set of line types:
Two more conventions matter from day one:
- Scale. Drawings are made to scale, for example 1:5, where 1 mm on paper represents 5 mm in real life. A shelf of 350 mm drawn at 1:5 becomes 350 / 5 = 70 mm on paper. A scale of 2:1 enlarges: a 14 mm component drawn at 2:1 is 28 mm on paper.
- Dimensioning. All sizes are given in millimetres, written above the dimension line, with neat arrowheads touching the extension lines. The number tells the truth even if the drawing is slightly out, builders work from the dimension, never from measuring the paper.
1.8 A first look at first-angle orthographic projection
A 3D object cannot be measured accurately from one picture, so working drawings show three separate 2D views of it: the front view, the top view and a side view. South Africa uses first-angle projection, which fixes where each view is placed on the page: the top view sits below the front view, and the view from the left is drawn on the right of the front view.
Study the step block above. The isometric view on the left shows the object in 3D. The three orthographic views on the right describe it exactly: the front view shows the step outline, the top view (below the front view) shows the step edge as a line across the width, and the left view shows the step height as a line. Chapter 2 teaches you to draw these views with instruments, to scale, with full dimensioning.
1.9 Summary
- Grade 9 learners identify the problem, need or opportunity themselves, from a real-life context.
- The design process, Investigate, Design, Make, Evaluate, Communicate, is a cycle, not a straight line, and evaluation happens throughout.
- A design brief states what will be designed and why; specifications are testable requirements; constraints are the limits of cost, time and materials.
- Gradient 1:12 with a rise of 600 mm needs a ramp of 600 x 12 = 7200 mm = 7,2 m.
- Realistic budgets include labour: R360 materials + R360 labour = R720 total.
- Line types, scale and dimensioning are the grammar of working drawings; first-angle orthographic projection places the top view below the front view and the left view on the right.