Chapter 1. Economic Systems FREE
1.1 The economic problem: needs, wants and scarcity
People have unlimited needs and wants, but every country has only a limited supply of resources. This clash between unlimited wants and limited resources is called scarcity, and it is the basic economic problem. Because of scarcity, every society is forced to make choices. Economists summarise these choices as three big questions:
- What should be produced? (food, houses, cars, services)
- How should it be produced? (with many workers or with machines; by the state or by private businesses)
- For whom should it be produced? (who receives the goods and services that are made)
The way a country answers these three questions is called its economic system.
1.2 What is an economic system?
An economic system is the way a country organises the production, distribution and consumption of goods and services. It determines who owns the factors of production, natural resources, labour, capital and entrepreneurship, and who makes the big economic decisions. The three major economic systems are the planned economy, the market economy and the mixed economy. In the real world no country is purely planned or purely market; every country sits somewhere on a line between the two extremes.
1.3 The planned economy
Origin. The planned economy grew out of the ideas of socialism and communism, especially the writings of Karl Marx in the nineteenth century. The former Soviet Union ran a planned economy for most of the twentieth century, and countries such as North Korea and Cuba still rely on strong central planning today.
Characteristics:
- The state owns most of the factors of production: factories, farms, mines and banks.
- A central planning authority decides what to produce, how to produce it and for whom.
- Prices, wages and production targets are set by the government, not by demand and supply.
- There is very little private ownership and very little competition.
Advantages. In theory everyone receives the basic necessities of life; official unemployment is low because the state creates jobs; services such as housing, education and health care are free or very cheap; large national projects can be carried out quickly because one authority controls all the resources.
Disadvantages. Producers have little incentive to work hard or to improve quality because they cannot earn profit; planners cannot know exactly what millions of consumers want, so shortages of some goods and surpluses of others are common; consumers have very little freedom of choice; long queues and poor quality goods were everyday features of the old planned economies.
1.4 The market economy
Origin. The market economy is built on the ideas of Adam Smith, whose famous book The Wealth of Nations appeared in 1776. Smith argued that when individuals pursue their own profit, an invisible hand guides resources to where society needs them most.
Characteristics:
- Private individuals and companies own most of the factors of production.
- Prices are determined by the interaction of demand and supply in markets.
- The profit motive drives production: businesses make what consumers are willing to pay for.
- Competition between businesses keeps prices down and quality up.
- The role of the government in the economy is small.
Advantages. Consumers enjoy a wide choice of goods and services; competition encourages efficiency, innovation and lower prices; hard work and good ideas are rewarded, which encourages economic growth.
Disadvantages. Income is divided very unevenly and the gap between rich and poor can become extreme; goods and services that do not earn profit, such as street lights and rural clinics, may not be provided; workers can be exploited and the environment can be damaged if there are no rules; unemployment can rise sharply in bad economic times.
1.5 The mixed economy
A mixed economy combines features of the planned system and the market system. Private businesses produce most goods and services and respond to demand and supply, while the government provides public services, owns some key industries and makes rules to protect workers, consumers and the environment.
Almost every modern country, including South Africa, runs a mixed economy. In South Africa:
- Private businesses, shops, farms, factories, banks and mines, produce most goods and services, and prices are mostly set by demand and supply.
- The state owns key enterprises such as Eskom (electricity) and Transnet (rail and ports).
- The government provides public schools, clinics and social grants, and collects taxes to pay for them.
- Laws such as the minimum wage and the National Credit Act regulate the market.
1.6 The global economy
The global economy is the network of all the economies of the world, linked together through international trade, investment, technology and travel. Countries sell goods and services to one another (exports) and buy from one another (imports). South Africa exports minerals such as gold and platinum, as well as fruit, wine and motor vehicles, and imports crude oil, machinery and electronics.
Because economies are linked, events in one country ripple across the world. A rise in the world oil price makes petrol more expensive in South Africa, which pushes up transport costs and food prices. In the same way, a good fruit harvest in South Africa creates jobs at home because overseas buyers order more. No economic system today operates in isolation: even strongly planned economies trade with the rest of the world.
Worked example 1.1: Classifying economic systems
Classify each scenario below as a planned, market or mixed economy, and give a reason.
- Scenario A: In country A the government owns all the farms and factories, and a state committee sets the price of bread.
- Scenario B: In country B almost all businesses are privately owned, prices are set by demand and supply, and the government plays almost no role in the economy.
- Scenario C: In country C private companies run the shops and factories, but the state owns the electricity supplier, provides free public schooling and sets a minimum wage.
Solution. Scenario A shows state ownership of the factors of production and state-set prices, so it is a planned economy. Scenario B shows private ownership, prices set by demand and supply, and a very small government role, so it is a market economy. Scenario C shows a strong private sector combined with state ownership and regulation, so it is a mixed economy.
Final answers: A = planned economy; B = market economy; C = mixed economy.
1.7 Comparing the three systems
| Feature | Planned economy | Market economy | Mixed economy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ownership of factors of production | Mostly the state | Mostly private | Both state and private |
| Who decides what to produce | Central planners | Consumers and businesses | Both, with the private sector leading |
| How prices are set | Fixed by the state | Demand and supply | Mostly demand and supply, with some state control |
| Consumer choice | Very limited | Very wide | Wide, with consumer protection |
| Examples | North Korea, Cuba | No pure example; Hong Kong comes closest | South Africa, United Kingdom, Germany |
Summary
- Scarcity forces every country to answer three questions: what, how and for whom to produce. The answers form its economic system.
- In a planned economy the state owns most factors of production and central planners make the decisions; choice is limited and shortages are common.
- In a market economy private owners, the profit motive and demand and supply drive the economy; choice is wide but inequality can grow.
- A mixed economy, like the economy of South Africa, combines a strong private sector with state ownership of key services and government regulation.
- The global economy links all national economies through trade and investment, so events in one country affect the others.