Chapter 1. What is history and how do we study the past FREE
When you walk through the District Six Museum in Cape Town, you see street signs, photographs and the names of families who were forcibly removed from their homes after 1966. None of that is the past itself, because the past is gone and cannot be visited. What you see is history: the careful work that people do to reconstruct, explain and argue about what happened, using whatever traces survive. This chapter asks what history actually is, how historians turn fragments into knowledge, and why two honest writers can study the same event and still disagree. These are the thinking tools you will use for every other chapter in this Grade 10 course.
1.1 The difference between the past and history
The past is everything that has ever happened. History is the organised study of selected parts of the past, written down and supported by evidence. A historian cannot record everything, so they choose what to investigate and which questions to ask. Because of this selection, history is always partly an interpretation, not a simple list of facts. When the Voortrekker Monument near Pretoria and a local oral tradition both describe the Battle of Blood River in 1838, they emphasise different things, because each is answering a different question and serving a different audience.
1.2 Primary and secondary sources
Historians work with two kinds of evidence. A primary source comes from the time being studied, such as a diary, a photograph, a treaty, a tax record or a clay pot. A secondary source is created later by someone studying the period, such as a textbook, a documentary or a journal article. The same object can change category depending on the question. A 2010 newspaper is a secondary source about the year 1838, but a primary source about South Africa in 2010.
- Primary: the original Dutch land grant for a Cape farm signed in 1700.
- Primary: a praise poem (izibongo) about Shaka recited by an eyewitness generation.
- Secondary: a 2015 history book that quotes and explains that land grant.
- Secondary: a school study guide summarising the reign of Shaka.
1.3 Evaluating sources: reliability, bias and usefulness
No source is simply true or false. Historians ask three practical questions. First, who made this source and why? This reveals bias, the way an author favours one side. Second, how reliable is it, meaning how likely is it to be accurate given who produced it and when? Third, how useful is it for the specific question being asked? A biased source is not worthless. A settler pamphlet attacking the Xhosa is unreliable about the Xhosa, yet very useful evidence of how settlers thought.
1.4 Cause, effect, change and continuity
History is not only about what happened but about why, and about what changed and what stayed the same. A cause is something that helps bring about an event; an effect or consequence is what follows from it. Causes are usually layered: a long-term cause builds up over many years, while a short-term trigger sets things off. Historians also weigh change against continuity, because even during a dramatic upheaval many ordinary things carry on unchanged.
1.5 Oral history, archaeology and many voices
For long stretches of the southern African past there are few written documents, so historians rely on oral history, traditions passed down by word of mouth, and on archaeology, the study of physical remains such as iron tools, grain pits and the stone walls of settlements like Mapungubwe. These methods let the voices of people who left no writing enter the record. Combining many kinds of evidence is called corroboration, and it makes a historical argument stronger.
- Written records favour those who could write, often officials and the wealthy.
- Oral testimony preserves memory, genealogy and meaning within a community.
- Archaeology reveals trade, diet and technology that documents never mention.
- Using all three together produces a more balanced and reliable history.
Mastering these tools, the difference between past and history, the testing of sources, and the analysis of cause and change, prepares you to study empires, revolutions and the transformation of southern Africa with a critical and fair mind throughout the rest of this course.